![]()
I. King County Recycled Product Procurement
The King County Recycled Product Procurement Policy (KCC 10.16, Executive Policy CON 7-1-2 (AEP)) directs County agencies to purchase products manufactured with recycled materials "wherever practicable". This annual report summarizes the progress made by the King County Recycled Product Procurement Program in implementation of this policy through June 30, 1997.
The policy reflects a long-term commitment on the part of King County to support recycling markets through County purchasing. This program has established King County as a national leader in municipal procurement of recycled materials. The County is maintaining this position of leadership through the efforts and accomplishments of County employees, who are actively pursuing ways to use recycled materials in new applications and working with vendors to refine the manufacture of viable and economical recycled products. This report describes the progress that agencies have made toward the goals of the policy.
The policy was revised and simplified in 1995 in response to enhancements in the guidelines of the United States Environmental Protection Agency (EPA) pursuant to Federal Executive Order 12873, and the experience of five years of implementation by County agencies. These revisions recognized a broader group of "environmentally preferable" products, streamlined the policy, and clarified accountabilities so that further revisions to Federal Guidance can be smoothly accommodated and implementation efforts easily enhanced.
EPA has no plans to "finalize" the proposed guidance, but many of the concepts and principles it contains are being tested for their applicability to purchasing decisions through pilot projects. The program will monitor and communicate information developed by EPA to County users as it becomes available.
The objective of the Recycled Product Procurement Program is to bring about fundamental change in the procurement priorities of the 10,000-plus employees of the County and its contractors. With the full participation of the people in the agencies who specify products, the County can attain its goal of buying recycled products "wherever practicable." The program supports the efforts of these people by providing information and technical assistance to help them identify economical and effective recycled products and by creating and maintaining contracts for their purchase. It helps agencies understand policy requirements and communicates specifications, contracts, and other practical information between County agencies, vendors, users, and other jurisdictions.
The program's collaborative approach, which provides information and guidance to County employees and relies on their expertise to evaluate procurement opportunities and revise procedures, is gradually changing the way that agencies view these opportunities. They are placing more emphasis on developing ways to increase the use of recycled and other environmentally preferable products, especially where these will reduce costs while still meeting rigorous performance standards.
The King County Recycled Product Procurement Policy calls upon each County agency to revise contracting and procurement procedures and specifications to increase the purchase of recycled and other environmentally preferable products. This program helps each agency to:
The Procurement Services Division administers the Recycled Product Procurement Program to facilitate the implementation of this policy by agencies. The program:
A number of factors challenge efforts to increase environmentally preferable purchasing:
The Program and County agencies are addressing these challenges by:
Purchase Summary--Paper Products
Recycled paper is specified for purchase through term-supply contracts. These centrally administered contracts enable agencies to purchase hundreds of paper products at low and consistent prices. They specify recycled paper whenever practicable and non-recycled paper is purchased only if recycled paper is not available within the 15% price-preference guidelines of the policy. Data from 1996/97 indicate the recently streamlined office supply system is maintaining high levels of recycled paper supply.
Recycled paper purchases have grown from 8% at the start of policy implementation in 1989 to 93% in 1996/97, exceeding the 60% goal established by policy. King County agencies purchased recycled paper goods valued at over One Million Dollars in 1996/97. Future purchase levels will fluctuate with variation in product availability and bid results, but program personnel expect to be able to continue to achieve these levels.
The table below shows the dollar value and percentage of total recycled paper purchases for 1996/97 by category.
| 1996/97 Recycled Paper Purchases | $ | % |
|---|---|---|
| Photocopy and Bond Paper | 364,169 | 99 |
| Paper Products, Miscellaneous | 386,456 | 87 |
| Printing Paper | 378,128 | 93 |
| Totals: | $1,128,753 | 93% |
Purchase Detail - Paper
King County purchases of paper fall into three general categories:
Purchase Summary - Non-Paper Products
The purchase of non-paper recycled-content products is less straightforward than that of paper products: these products are often not well-established in the marketplace and they are typically purchased through complex engineering and construction contracts. Purchases depend on the specifications of designers, based on project-specific materials requirements; acceptance by State, Federal, and other external standards organizations; product performance, price and availability; the ability of contractors to deliver the expertise required for their use; and other factors.
The table below represents non-paper recycled product purchases from term supply and construction contracts, and direct purchases. Term contract purchases are captured through direct-reporting required of vendors by the Recycled Product Procurement Program. The Program's liaison network captures data when agencies purchase products by other means. Such purchases occur in construction or other service contracts, not tied to term supply contracts, or are executed by "direct voucher" for evaluation purposes or for purchases too small for a formal term contract.
The program is helping County agencies institutionalize the routine purchase of recycled materials and in 1996/97 King County purchased non-paper recycled products valued at over $800,000.
| Commodity Purchased | Per | Units | $'s |
|---|---|---|---|
| Aggregate, Recycled Concrete | Ton | 20,546 | 137,550 |
| Aggregate, Recycled Glass | Pounds | 400 | 72 |
| Antifreeze, Remanufactured | Gallon | 2,287 | 10,920 |
| Can Liners, Recycled | Case | 3,866 | 83,800 |
| Compost | Yard | 6,039 | 146,760 |
| Oil, Re-refined | Gallon | 13,481 | 32,292 |
| Plastic Lumber | Each | 315 | 11,000 |
| Paint, Recycled | Gallon | 30 | 300 |
| Paint, Recycled Glass | Gallon | 250 | 4,500 |
| Shredded Wood | Yard | 131,040 | 172,291 |
| Shredded Wood Mulch | Yard | 640 | 4,801 |
| Tire Retreading | N/A | N/A | 82,280 |
| Toner Cartridges, Remanufactured | Each | 3,078 | 119,210 |
| Total Dollars: | $805,776 | ||
| * 1st & 2nd Quarter only for Roads division construction contracts | |||
Savings Summary
The Recycled Product Procurement Program identifies opportunities for agencies to use recycled materials that reduce expense and meet performance requirements. In 1997, the County saved almost $500,000 by purchasing such materials. This table represents dollars saved in 1997 by commodity.
| Commodity | $'s | Savings |
|---|---|---|
| Toner cartridges | 234,000 | material |
| Shredded wood-waste | 130,000 | material |
| Shredded wood mulch | 3,000 | material |
| Concrete aggregate | 20,000 | material |
| Plastic Lumber | 7,500 | material and maintenance |
| Glass sand | 250 | material |
| Tire Retreading | 80,000 | material |
| Total Dollars: | $474,750 |
Purchase Detail - Non-Paper
Purchases of non-paper recycled materials require evaluation and application-development by engineers, architects, and other professionals. This section provides details of some of the ways in which County agencies are addressing the challenges presented by these materials.
The same company that supplied the glass for the traction grit has also developed a material for use as a sandblasting medium for cleaning machine parts, with a material cost 45% lower, at $0.18 per pound, than the $0.35 per pound cost of the garnet material the Transit Division is accustomed to using. Tests of this material were planned in brake-shoe cleaning operations by Transit Division in 1996/97, but not conducted.
The "closed-loop" oil recycling program, under which recycled oil was directed to re-refining, was not offered by bidders for the current contract, so used oil is being recycled by a vendor who supplies it to the "bunker-fuel" market.
The Renton Maintenance Facility of Fleet Administration Division is evaluating the installation of on-site systems that will allow them to recover the energy from Waste oil to heat shop buildings.
The Maintenance and Facilities Division of the Department of Parks and Cultural Resources used 20 gallons of recycled interior latex paint from a local vendor in their offices and is planning to test a two-part epoxy exterior paint on picnic tables. Parks personnel have noted that this vendor is the first they have evaluated that is able to match the desired colors. The vendor also accepts left-over and outdated paint for recycling, reducing disposal costs.
The Kingdome paint shop tested recycled interior latex paint in its administrative offices. The results were good, the paint was economical, and Stadium personnel plan to purchase this paint in the future. They also tested a two-part latex-epoxy (60% recycled content) on the floors and walls of a hallway leading from the athletic locker rooms to the playing field. In this severe-traffic area, the paint was too easily scuffed by the rubber wheels of equipment and rubber shoe-soles. The paint shop Supervisor continues to provide the vendor with advice about product improvement and will evaluate new versions of this paint as they are developed.
Plastic Lumber
- Fleet Applications
The Renton Maintenance Facility of the Fleet Administration Division now specifies
recycled plastic lumber for truck-bed sideboards
its dump-trucks. When the Division required new trucks to be outfitted with recycled
plastic, the truck-equipment vendor adopted this material as a standard option because of
its superior performance and lower life-cycle cost. The division is retrofitting all of
its virgin-lumber truck equipment with material supplied by this vendor, with expenditures
for over 40 sideboards totaling nearly $6,000. Quality old growth fir is scarce and easily
damaged, but recycled plastic is very impact resistant. The replacement schedule for these
boards has been reduced to 17 a year, compared to 53 a year when wood was used. This
represents a savings of $2,500 a year in material costs.
Plastic Lumber - Parks Applications
Parks Division purchases plastic lumber for bench slat
replacement, bollards, and special utility applications. For many of these applications,
plastic lumber is preferred for its resistance to decay, graffiti and chemical damage.
This material results in significant cost-savings when used as a substitute for chemically
treated lumber in applications involving contact with soil and water and in other harsh
environments. Parks Division recently consulted with the Parks Department of the City of
Seattle to design and build a kiosk for Luther Burbank Park using a plastic and wood
composite material. Parks personnel were pleased with the outcome and expect to develop
other applications for it.
In 1997, a new playground structure installed at Fort Dent by the Parks Division was constructed from 85% recycled material. Design work is being done for the same type of playground structure at Beaver Lake and Lake Wilderness to be installed in 1998.
Plastic Lumber - Roads Applications
The Bridge Unit of the Roads Division is testing $7,000 worth of plastic lumber for use in
repairing timber bridges. The vendor worked with County engineers to reinforce and modify
the product to meet performance requirements. Long-term performance will be monitored in
the normal course of Bridge Unit's performance program, but initial results indicate that
plastic lumber deflects excessively ("deflection of reinforced recycled plastic
lumber is still about 5 times greater than wood"), which will limit its use to
applications with low structural requirements. In a November, 1996 report to the Marketing
Commission, which funded the project, the unit supervisor wrote "the product
certainly has merit, although it is not ideal for the application of replacement of
wingwall dimensional lumber". Other user reports indicated that the material was too
expensive, was not readily available, and lacked industry standards.
Plastic Lumber - Stadium Applications
Stadium Administration Maintenance Division personnel use recycled plastic lumber to
replace wooden 4"x4" "channel
boards" to secure the Kingdome artificial turf. The performance of this material
is superior to that of virgin lumber and has demonstrated a longer replacement schedule
and lower life cycle cost. The Kingdome saves over $5,000 each year by using this
material. This application has generated interest from stadia around the country and has
been adopted by both the Minneapolis Metrodome and B.C. Place in Vancouver B.C. Canada.
The stadium has also used recycled plastic for sign-blanks and for "skid pads"
for the feet of portable bleachers, both with good results.
Plastic Lumber - Transit Applications
Transit Division has adopted the use of recycled plastic lumber with 50% wood fiber as an
element in the fabrication of its bus shelters, replacing the "clear" Douglas
Fir formerly used. This application may consume significant amounts of material, as
Transit Division maintains over 6,000 shelters. The Division purchased 275 boards for
$5500 last year.
A demonstration of shredded wood-waste at the King County Jail led to a collaboration between the vendor and the West-Point wastewater treatment facility of the Department of Natural Resources. The producer has opened a new market based on the product developed through that collaboration and is experiencing steady growth in sales of this product. This development, in turn, prompted the Department of Construction and Facilities Management to purchase over 600 cubic yards of this material, at a cost of nearly $5,000, for a holding area for nursery-stock at the King County Airport, mulch around the Administration Building, and other applications.
Agency Liaison Network Activities
The Recycled Product Procurement Program helps agencies develop practicable and fiscally responsible ways to increase the use of recycled products. It provides them with recycled product information through a network of people who act as liaisons between the program and the agencies. It also uses that network to share evaluation results and specifications that have been developed by users between agencies and makes them available to suburban cities and other jurisdictions. It also helps agencies create evaluation opportunities and revise contract administration procedures to develop ways to routinely use recycled materials whenever practicable.
During the past two years, the re-organization of King County agencies to incorporate those formerly within the METRO organization nearly doubled the number of employees in the County to 12,000, making it necessary to establish new liaisons and renew existing ones in reorganized agencies.
Special Information Programs
The program hosted informational tours, meetings, and other events to provide information on recycled product procurement opportunities to agencies:
Program personnel previewed sites for planning future tours:
E-Mail Procurement Bulletin
The Program initiated routine distribution of information about opportunities to purchase environmentally preferable products by e-mail. Recipients include all participants in the program's County liaison network, as well as other interested parties in King County and elsewhere.
An archive of bulletins is available on the World-Wide-Web
King Street Project The Department of Construction and Facilities Management is overseeing a private development project to construct a new facility in which the County Departments of Transportation and Natural Resources plan to become tenants. The design calls for an eight-story, 300,000 square-foot building, to be situated on King Street, in Pioneer Square. The Recycled Product Procurement Program has developed information about recycled materials for evaluation by the architect, developer, and their contractors. The Department of Natural Resources has asked the developer to try to adhere to a number of environmentally-preferable building principles in this project, including the use of several recycled materials. The Department is applying for funding to produce guidelines for environmentally preferable building that could be useful to County agencies in future projects and could be further developed as a model to the community. Material selection will take place over the next 2 years and the building is expected to be occupied in late 1999. The King County Commission for Marketing Recyclable Materials plans to develop interpretive materials to share the messages of environmentally preferable building practices with the community.
The King County Recycled Product Procurement Program maintains a site on the world-wide web as a resource to participants in the King County program as well as others in the community.
Municipalities and other organizations throughout the nation are beginning to recognize the difference they can make to the environment by purchasing environmentally preferable products. Thanks to the leadership of King County agencies, purchasers are now able to use the internet to find information that will help them understand their opportunities in this confusing new area. Over 15,000 visitors entered this web site in the six months from January through June of 1997, more than twice the number of visits during that period last year. People from all over the world are taking advantage of this site and these contacts are bringing new information that County agencies, suburban cities, and others can use as we all try to develop new applications for recycled and other environmentally preferable products.
In 1996/97, the web-site was reorganized, the model policy was broadened to include a greater range of environmentally preferable materials, and several new "fact sheets" were developed.
Web-site contents:
Printed copies of this information may be obtained from the program. Send requests by e-mail or call (206) 296-4210.
The King County Recycled Product Procurement Program offers its experience in support of the planning, policy-development, and procurement education activities of various organizations, and jurisdictions. Program personnel participated in the delivery of public information and technical assistance programs conducted by the following organizations during 1996-97:
The program provides technical assistance to users by telephone, fax, mail, and e-mail, as well as through the internet. The program provided assistance to, and exchanged information with, several suburban cities in King County, as well as state and federal agencies, and other users.
A key to the success of the King County Recycled Product Procurement Program has been the exchange of practical information with other users of these unfamiliar materials. Many of these exchanges have come as a consequence of exposure through national magazines, newspapers, and other publications. Among the publications which featured the King County Recycled Product Procurement Program in 1996/97 were:
The King County Recycled Product Procurement Policy (Executive Policy CON 7-1-2, A/EP) was revised in 1995 to accommodate changes to the procurement guidelines of the United States Environmental Protection Agency and to reflect the County's four years of experience in policy implementation. The policy now enables the County to use the mechanisms developed by the Recycled Product Procurement Program to increase the procurement of other "environmentally preferable" products and expand the commitment of County agencies to other environmentally preferable initiatives such as reduction of the use of toxic materials, waste-reduction, energy conservation, "green-building," etc.
The revised policy is available on the World-Wide-Web at:
In 1996-97, the program began to research environmentally preferable procurement opportunities beyond recycled content products. For example, it provided information to agencies, through the liaison network, on recycling of fluorescent lamps, energy efficient lighting and air conditioning, and on recycling hard-to-recycle items.
Program personnel continued to promote the development of recycled and environmentally preferable procurement policies in suburban cities by providing technical support to the Solid Waste Division's Waste Reduction/Recycling Section. The model was revised in 1997 to broaden the range of environmentally preferable products. Program personnel also provide direct technical assistance to suburban cities for policy implementation, including sharing contracts, specifications, and procurement strategies.
Solid Waste Division reported that nineteen suburban cities had adopted recycled product procurement policies based on the King County model as of July, 1997:
| Bellevue | Burien | Carnation | Des Moines |
| Duvall | Enumclaw | Federal Way | Issaquah |
| Kent | Lake Forest Park | Mercer Island | Normandy Park |
| North Bend | Redmond | Renton | SeaTac |
| Snoqualmie | Tukwila | Woodinville |
King county agencies support markets for recycled materials by participating in the Recycled Product Procurement Program. Other County programs making important contributions include:
Appendix: Environmentally Preferable Procurement Initiatives of Agencies
All King County agencies purchase recycled paper products, remanufactured toner cartridges, and recycled office supplies, through contracts maintained by the Recycled Product Procurement Program. In addition, County agencies are participating in the development of applications for a wide range of other materials by conducting pilot-projects and evaluations.
Department of Construction & Facilities Management
Department of Natural Resources
Department of Parks & Cultural Resources
Department of Stadium Administration
Department of Transportation
E-mail
Return to
Environmental Purchasing Menu
Updated: December, 1999
King County
| News | Services | Comments | SearchLinks to external sites do not constitute
endorsements by King County.
By visiting this and other King County web pages,
you expressly agree to be bound by terms and conditions of the site.
The details.